Charles Dalziel: The Shocking History of AC and DC
Most people think a steady DC shock would be worse to hold than AC. On a sixty-hertz circuit, alternating current passes through zero a hundred and twenty times a second, so it seems as if the hand should get a chance to let go. Direct current never lets up.
That answer is backwards.
In the 1940s and 1950s, Charles Francis Dalziel, a University of California, Berkeley engineering professor, measured electric shock on volunteers and on himself. What he found still matters for the batteries, chargers, and inverters in today's workplaces.
Dalziel separated shock into clear endpoints. Perception is only the faintest current a person notices. Let-go current is different: the most current someone can hold and still open the hand, using the muscles the current is stimulating. He measured it in 134 men and 28 women, then chose a cautious point: the current that only one person in two hundred could not release. That came to about nine milliamperes for men and six for women. Above that, he warned, strength fades with pain and fatigue.
Then he ran the same kind of test with smooth, steady DC. The volunteers felt internal heating more than a locked grip, and in every case they could release the electrode. The jolts were real, especially when the current was made or broken, but the hand did not clamp the way it did on AC. He called the DC stopping point a "release current," a psychological limit rather than the physiological limit of the let-go tests.
The key correction is that muscle lock comes from change, not from a steady push. A motor nerve responds when current starts, stops, rises, or falls. Sixty-hertz AC never stops changing, so the twitches fuse into one grip. The zero crossings do not free the hand; they keep retriggering it. Steady DC changes at the edges of contact and holds still in between.
That law cuts both ways. Dalziel found that even a small ripple on DC, the kind a filtered power supply can leave, made let-go "materially less" than pure battery current. Much of today's "DC" is rectified, pulsed, or switched. The useful question is not only "AC or DC?" but whether the current is steady or changing, and by how much.
None of this makes steady DC harmless. The interruption jolt can throw a person. Steady current heats tissue and can drive electrolysis. At high enough current, and depending on duration, DC can also affect the heart. Where workplace voltage rules give separate figures, the DC number is often higher, and one phrase keeps returning: ripple-free.
Dalziel did not leave the problem in the laboratory. In 1961 he invented the ground-fault circuit interrupter, later patented as a miniature differential circuit breaker, so protection would not depend on the ability to let go.
On Tuesday, November 17, 2026, ElecTrain releases Charles Dalziel: The Shocking History of AC and DC, a film that follows that research and what it means in the field.
Watch it on the ElecTrain LLC YouTube channel, and visit www.ElecTrain.com.